Nemo’s War (Second Edition) Review

Nemo's War
Exploration/Adventure
Victory Point Games
Chris Taylor
Ian O'Toole
1 (or up to 4, but really, 1)
Excellent solitaire gameplay, occasionally shrieking in frustration at dice

Nemo's War is, simply a magnificent solitaire experience, and an excellent co-op besides. Tough, beautifully produced, and with enough variety that it will keep taunting you back for more.  We love this one.

Ok, so I don’t review many solitaire games.  There are a handful that I do enjoy, but for the most part, I like my games social.  That said, and to completely spoil this review from the get-go, I think Nemo’s War is a truly excellent single player experience from end to hair-pullingly-difficult end.

All laid out, it can look pretty intimidating.

Rob:  Wow, yeah, I had no idea this one would be such a winner for you.  I knew that I wanted it the moment I looked at it, but you’re usually so fussy about solo games.  But I’m happy you like it, so let’s take a look at what this game has submerged beneath…

Andrew:  Please don’t, it’s too soon for-

Rob:  …its depths.

Now, in all fairness, Nemo’s War is not necessarily a solitaire game, despite the fact that it’s how we primarily have played it, and we’ll talk more about that in a bit.  But for the moment, to describe the experience of gameplay, that’s the view we’re going to take.  Just a heads-up.

Nemo’s War is, at first, an intimidatingly sweeping game.  This second edition, successfully Kickstarted by Victory Point Games, is beautifully produced and sits huge on the table, just daring you to question the gravity of its design.

Each turn, you will get to decide where to spend your limited action points.

Andrew:  When I first got it to the table, Nemo’s War looked (ugh) vast – I was immediately concerned that it would be overly complex, to the point of being difficult to engage.  But while there are certainly lots of little rules and systems to keep track of, Nemo’s War’s physical design does a fantastic job of giving you nearly all the information you’ll need at a glance.

So much is right there on the board. It’s an excellent choice.

Broadly, Nemo’s War features a campaign that features the events of the literary classic 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea.  You will encounter a different scene from the novel each turn, drawn from a randomly-constructed deck.  Each of these event cards is unique, representing either a danger that the crew must face, a natural wonder to be navigated, warships for the Nautilus to sink, or treasure to be recovered.

Rob:  Like you just said, these cards are all unique, and since you only use a randomized subset of those cards, there is plenty of variety for you to explore even though there is a finite number of event cards.  And it’s really impossible to predict what’s coming, which makes the tension even higher.

Nemo’s motive defines success in each game.

Your mission in Nemo’s War is simple – survive to the end of the event deck before the crew, the ship, or the spirit of Nemo himself gives out.  Along the way, you’ll have the opportunity to modify and upgrade the Nautilus, gather treasure, explore, and sink enemy ships.  Now, how much any of these activities contribute to your final score depend on Nemo’s ‘motive’ – there are 4 potential scoring systems, one of which you’ll pick at the beginning of the game.  This motivation rewards you more or less for certain activities (for example, the Science motivation earns more points for discoveries and treasures, while the Anti-Imperialism motive earns the most points by liberating islands and beating back warships).

Various fleets of ships will appear during your game, from the harmless to the deadly.

Andrew:  The fact that the game gives you a final score can sometimes feel a little superfluous – just making it to the end of the event deck can be a solid challenge.

Rob:  For real.  Nemo’s motive give you something to shoot for, as well as establishing certain game-end conditions, so they can guide your gameplay a bit – you might favor attacking ships or exploring extra events, etc.  But yeah, sometimes it’s hard enough just to survive.

Nearly every challenge in Nemo’s War is resolved with a roll of the dice, and higher numbers always favor you.  Whether you are sinking a ship or killing a shark with a knife, you will roll some dice, possibly add a modifier (or penalty), and hope you’ve beaten the target number.  Nearly every challenge will let you ‘exert’ one or more of your 3 resources (Hull, Crew, and Nemo himself) to get a bonus.  But these exertions are a gamble – you lose nothing should your attempt succeed, but if you fail, whatever resource you exerted will drop, leaving you with ever-dwindling hull integrity, crew cohesion, and sane leadership.

The crew is being used to give a +3 bonus, but will drop should the roll fail.

Nemo’s War draws a tremendous number of thematic beats from the legendary novel.  The event cards are obviously inspired by specific scenes and lines, but even the way combat is resolved, with the otherwise-weaponless Nautilus ramming through the hull of various ships, fits into the narrative of the source material.

Andrew:  That said, I absolutely love how you can, over the course of the game, potentially upgrade the Nautilus.  By harvesting salvage from ships you sink, you can add all kinds of thematic improvements to the vessel, potentially turning it into a truly monstrous craft.

Rob:  Yeah, including that literal ‘Monstrous Design’ upgrade, that makes people think it’s a sea monster so that your Notoriety doesn’t increase as fast.  It’s all super clever.

Upgrading the Nautilus will likely be key to your victory.

Notoriety is a value which tracks how the world sees Nemo’s actions – sinking ships and certain events will increase it, and the more seriously the world’s nations take you, the more devastating the resistance you will encounter.  Too-high Notoriety will also end the game in a loss, depending on Nemo’s motivation for that session.

Iconic

Once you have worked your way through the event deck, for better or worse, and if you haven’t lost due to one of the several game-ending conditions, you will tally up your score (as modified by Nemo’s motive), and you will bask in your glorious victory…or possibly lose in the epilogue, if your score isn’t high enough.

Rob:  Like we said, it feels somewhat silly that there even is a score – Nemo’s War is tough, and just making it through is victory enough, as far as I’m concerned.

Andrew:  Totally.  But at the same time, getting this or that epilogue is just icing on the cake as far as I’m concerned – what matters here is that Nemo’s War is an absolute blast to play.

Key crew members

Nemo’s War is a deeper solitaire experience than most.  While there are certainly several options per turn and there is almost always a feeling of being slightly behind where you need to be, the mechanics are accessible and engaging…as long as you’re on board for gambling with your resources and potentially shrieking in blind fury as your dice fail on what SHOULD BE an easy roll.

Andrew:  For me, Nemo’s War hits a lot of the beats I enjoy about games like Pandemic – that sense of rising tension and ever-tightening board conditions.  I love trying to stay ahead of the disaster, despite how easy it can be to fall way behind.

Do well and the epilogue book will define your glorious victory!…

Rob:  For me, it’s more like this big puzzle – each turn, after you resolve your events, you need to decide what you’re going to do with your limited actions, and, yeah, cringe in controlled horror every time you roll your dice.  But in, like, a really fun way.

Andrew:  Let’s talk about production for a second – this printing of Nemo’s War was successfully Kickstarted, and the polish it brings is truly great.

…Or chronicle your miserable defeat.

Rob:  Totally.  The board is huge for a solitaire game, but it’s fantastic because it delivers so many rules reminders and necessary information right on the board.  After my first couple of plays, I didn’t even feel like I needed the instructions anymore – it’s all right there.  Aside from the rules for constructing the event deck; I wish they had fit that in somewhere.

Andrew:  Ugh, nit-pick.  The art is great, too.  Scenes from the novel are depicted intriguingly, the graphic layout of the board and the cards (not to mention the iconography) is intuitive, and I love this interpretation of the Nautilus.

Cooperative rules for 4 players. We think it’s a touch superfluous.

As we said toward the beginning, Nemo’s War is not strictly a solitaire game, though we think it was clearly designed to be one.  Included in this edition are rules for dividing roles and responsibilities between multiple players and moving the Captain role around the table, turning Nemo’s War into a cooperative (or semi-cooperative) game.

Rob:  Eh.  The co-op rules seem tacked on – they don’t change the mechanics any, really, aside from putting some rules in place about when to change which player is captain.

Andrew:  That said, I’ve played Nemo’s War ‘faux-op’ a couple of times, with me and Jess simply making decisions together (rather than dividing who makes which decision formally), and I found it equally satisfying an experience as playing it alone.

Sinking ships around the world can be valuable, if Nemo’s motives are right.

Rob:  Yep. Nemo’s War  makes for a solid co-op experience; I’m just saying you can get it without actually using the cooperative rules included in the game.

With a game like Nemo’s War, you have to be ready for what you’re getting into.  It’s a tough game, with lots of dice rolling, small victories, and bitter losses.  You’ll have to make decisions every turn, and on some turns it may feel like there are no good decisions to be had.  On the other hand, those small victories can really start to add up, and Nemo’s War never feels unfair (besides that general feeling of unfairness native to nearly all ‘you against the board’ games, where there are simply too many threats and not enough resources).

Amassing treasure is always useful.

Andrew:  So, we like this one, is what we’ve been saying.

Rob:  Absolutely. Nemo’s War is up there with my favorite solitaire games.  Sure, it takes longer and needs more real estate than something like Samurai Spirit or Onirim, but the experience it provides is satisfying and engaging.

Andrew:  Agreed on all points, and I actually find it to be a really enjoyable cooperative experience, too.  This one’s a winner.

For players interested in its particular type of gameplay and challenge, Nemo’s War is an excellent title.  This second edition printing is beautifully produced and well designed, making for a truly enjoyable adventure.  We highly recommend checking it out!

(Gameosity received a review copy of Nemo’s War.  We were not otherwise compensated.)

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *